International Council for Education Quality Certification
Verify a certificateSubmit a complaint or concernContact ICEQC

Thematic Research Report series

Thematic Research Reports

241 complete publications covering the years 2005 to 2026.

Showing 12 of 12 results

241 publications in this series

ICEQC-R-2023-13

Thematic Research Report

Generative Artificial Intelligence in Education and Research: Human Oversight, Privacy and Age-Appropriate Use

A standards interpretation of educational purpose, responsibility, evidence, data protection and learner safeguards

UNESCO's guidance for generative artificial intelligence in education and research was published within this report's evidence period. For generative artificial intelligence in education and research, the proposition has a direct bearing on the issue under review within Executive summary: whether human oversight, privacy and age-appropriate safeguards govern educational use; the competent body should identify the affected population, decision authority and review point. It provides a contemporaneous human-centred governance reference. This report interprets educational purpose, human responsibility, privacy and age-appropriate use without treating the existence of guidance as evidence that institutions have implemented it.

Research category
Standards Interpretation
Report archetype
Standards Interpretive Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2023-12

Thematic Research Report

Education for Peace, Human Rights and Sustainable Development after the 2023 Recommendation

A policy synthesis of access, continuity, reopening, institutional duties and correction

Education continuity during COVID-19 is a continuing public duty under altered and uncertain conditions. For education for peace, rights and sustainable development, the proposition has a direct bearing on the issue under review within Executive summary: whether the 2023 Recommendation is translated into curriculum, institutional practice and public accountability; the competent body should identify the affected population, decision authority and review point. Closure, remote provision, partial reopening and renewed interruption can coexist across places and levels. Authorities should preserve entitlement, learner contact, teaching, support, records, progression and remedy while applying proportionate health-related rules issued by competent bodies.

Research category
Industry Policy and Regional Regulatory Analysis
Report archetype
Policy and Regulatory Synthesis
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2023-11

Thematic Research Report

Technology in Education: Governance in the Interests of Learners

A policy synthesis on educational purpose, rights, evidence, professional authority and public accountability

Governance in the interests of learners begins with public educational purpose. Technology should be selected, used and reviewed because it supports a defined service for learners and educators, not because availability, commercial pressure or institutional fashion creates its own justification. Public authorities remain responsible for rights, quality, equitable access, continuity and remedy.

Research category
Industry Policy and Regional Regulatory Analysis
Report archetype
Policy and Regulatory Synthesis
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2023-09

Thematic Research Report

Academic Integrity and Assessment Design in the Presence of Generative Technologies

A quality improvement study of diagnostic evidence, curriculum planning, staffing, materials and review

Wider variation in learner attainment should be addressed as an instructional and system-capacity question, not as a reason to lower entitlement or blame learners and teachers. For academic integrity amid generative technologies, the proposition has a direct bearing on the issue under review within Executive summary: whether assessment design preserves valid evidence, transparency and proportionate judgement; the competent body should identify the affected population, decision authority and review point. Disruption, uneven access, prior exclusion, language, disability, mobility and different learning histories can widen the range within a class. Teachers require useful evidence, curriculum guidance, time, materials, manageable groups and specialist support.

Research category
Quality Improvement Methods
Report archetype
Quality Improvement Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2023-08

Thematic Research Report

Digital Education Investment: Access, Use and Evidence of Educational Benefit

A comparative indicator study of expenditure, usable service, participation, learning and distribution

Digital education investment should be reported through a chain from public expenditure and acquired resources to usable access, educational participation, learning and distributional effect. Expenditure, devices, licences, connections and registrations describe inputs or activities. None establishes educational benefit without evidence concerning who could use the service, how it supported teaching and what changed.

Research category
Data and Indicator Research
Report archetype
Comparative Indicator Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2023-07

Thematic Research Report

International Comparisons of Learning after Pandemic Disruption: Interpretive Limits

A comparative indicator study of constructs, populations, baselines, disruption and uncertainty

International comparison after pandemic disruption requires a common construct and a transparent account of unequal opportunity. Countries and populations experienced different closure periods, remote arrangements, return patterns, curriculum changes and assessment conditions. A score difference cannot be attributed to disruption without evidence separating these conditions from prior trends, population change and measurement differences.

Research category
Data and Indicator Research
Report archetype
Comparative Indicator Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2023-06

Thematic Research Report

Connectivity Is Not Participation: Measuring Effective Access to Digital Learning

A comparative indicator study of household access, institutional provision, participation and educational use

The digital divide in emergency education is not captured by a single measure of internet access. For measurement of effective access to digital learning, the proposition has a direct bearing on the issue under review within Executive summary: whether connectivity results in sustained, supported educational participation; the competent body should identify the affected population, decision authority and review point. Educational use depends on a suitable device, affordable and reliable connectivity, electricity, accessible content, learner capability, household conditions, teacher interaction and institutional support. An indicator should identify which link it observes and should not infer the rest.

Research category
Data and Indicator Research
Report archetype
Comparative Indicator Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2023-05

Thematic Research Report

Public Procurement Standards for Digital Education Systems

Standards interpretation for educational purpose, accessibility, rights, evidence, cost and public responsibility

Public procurement for digital education systems is an exercise of educational and public authority. A contract does not transfer the State's duties concerning equal access, privacy, accessibility, safeguarding, continuity, fair treatment, information and remedy. Procurement standards should therefore connect educational purpose and learner rights to specifications, evaluation, contract management and exit.

Research category
Standards Interpretation
Report archetype
Standards Interpretive Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2023-04

Thematic Research Report

Implementation Readiness following Entry into Force of the Global Convention on Higher Education

A policy synthesis of competent authorities, fair recognition, information, records and review

The UNESCO Global Convention on the Recognition of Qualifications concerning Higher Education entered into force on 5 March 2023. By this report's 13 July cutoff, entry into force is a legal and institutional status for states bound according to the Convention's terms; it is not evidence that every recognition body, information arrangement or applicant pathway was implementation-ready.

Research category
Industry Policy and Regional Regulatory Analysis
Report archetype
Policy and Regulatory Synthesis
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2023-03

Thematic Research Report

Fair Recognition Procedures under a Global Qualifications Framework

A global standards interpretation of competent authority, evidence, substantial difference, reasons and review

The Global Compact on Refugees was affirmed by the United Nations General Assembly on 17 December 2018 and is within this report's evidence period. For fair recognition under a global qualifications framework, the proposition has a direct bearing on the issue under review within Executive summary: whether applicants receive timely, reasoned and reviewable recognition decisions; the competent body should identify the affected population, decision authority and review point. It provides a framework for more predictable and equitable responsibility-sharing and addresses inclusion in national systems, including education. At the 25 December cut-off, the Compact is an adopted international framework; it is not evidence that national laws, finance, school capacity or learner outcomes have already changed.

Research category
Standards Interpretation
Report archetype
Standards Interpretive Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2023-02

Thematic Research Report

Evaluating Educational Technology before System-Wide Adoption

A quality-improvement study of educational purpose, bounded trials, equity, evidence and authorised decisions

System-wide adoption of educational technology should follow, not precede, a reasoned account of educational need, viable alternatives, access conditions, institutional capacity, rights, cost and evidence. A tool may function as specified while failing to improve the learner-facing service. Procurement, connection, registration and use are activities; none establishes educational benefit by itself.

Research category
Quality Improvement Methods
Report archetype
Quality Improvement Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2023-01

Thematic Research Report

Strengthening Institutional Decisions on Technology through Pilots and Independent Evidence

A quality improvement study of educational purpose, bounded trials, equity, evidence and correction

An institutional technology decision should begin with an educational need, not a product category. For institutional technology decisions based on pilots and independent evidence, the proposition has a direct bearing on the issue under review within Executive summary: whether adoption follows demonstrated educational benefit and reviewable safeguards; the competent body should identify the affected population, decision authority and review point. The institution should identify the learner-facing condition to improve, existing evidence, affected population, alternatives and authority. A pilot can reduce uncertainty where it is bounded, reversible and designed to answer a decision question. Adoption should not precede evidence merely because a tool is available.

Research category
Quality Improvement Methods
Report archetype
Quality Improvement Study
Geographic scope
Global