International Council for Education Quality Certification
Verify a certificateSubmit a complaint or concernContact ICEQC

Thematic Research Report series

Thematic Research Reports

241 complete publications covering the years 2005 to 2026.

Showing 12 of 241 results

241 publications in this series

ICEQC-R-2007-03

Thematic Research Report

Regional Disparities in Early Childhood Provision: A Resource and Access Profile

A global comparative indicator study of availability, participation, workforce, infrastructure, household circumstances and the limits of regional comparison

Evidence concerning executive summary should establish a country can therefore appear to have little provision because important forms of care are not counted, or broad coverage because enrolment places are recorded without evidence that children attend. This matters because the first requirement of a regional profile is to establish what provision, population and service period each indicator represents. Early childhood care and education occupies an uncertain place in many national information systems. Services may be administered by education, health, social welfare, local government, private providers or community organisations, with different age ranges and reporting duties.

Research category
Data and Indicator Research
Report archetype
Comparative Indicator Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2007-02

Thematic Research Report

Transparent Recognition Decisions: Evidence, Consistency and the Interests of Learners

A global standards-interpretive study of qualification assessment, substantial difference, procedural fairness, mobility and accountable decision records

Recognition determines whether prior education can be used for further study, professional preparation, employment or another legitimate purpose. The decision affects time, cost, mobility and the learner’s ability to continue an educational pathway. It should therefore be based on relevant evidence, consistent standards and a procedure that can be understood and challenged.

Research category
Standards Interpretation
Report archetype
Standards Interpretive Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2007-01

Thematic Research Report

Observation, Feedback and Professional Learning in Early Years Settings

A quality-improvement study of low-inference evidence, professional dialogue, practitioner enquiry and verified change in children’s daily experience

Observation has public value only when reliable observation records lead to an appropriate response. A setting visit, judgement or published report does not by itself protect children or improve teaching. The quality function lies in the complete sequence: defining the standard; gathering sufficient evidence; distinguishing fact from interpretation; determining significance and responsibility; requiring or supporting professional learning action; verifying implementation; and closing the matter only when the relevant condition has changed or the observation record has been lawfully reconsidered.

Research category
Quality Improvement Methods
Report archetype
Quality Improvement Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2006-13

Thematic Research Report

Interpreting Educational Accessibility under the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities

A global standards-interpretive study of non-discrimination, inclusion, reasonable accommodation and equal educational participation

On 13 December 2006, the United Nations General Assembly adopted the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and its Optional Protocol. As at 27 December 2006, the Convention has not yet opened for signature and is not in force. Its adopted text nevertheless provides a clear international standard for examining disability, equality, accessibility and inclusive education.

Research category
Standards Interpretation
Report archetype
Standards Interpretive Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2006-11

Thematic Research Report

Institutional Strategies for Sustained Literacy Improvement in Low-Participation Communities

A global quality-improvement study of institutional reach, continuity, learning conditions, participation, accountability and durable capability

Low participation in literacy provision is seldom explained by an absence of interest in learning. It more often reflects an institutional failure to make a credible offer: provision is distant or irregular; teaching times conflict with paid and unpaid work; the language of instruction is unfamiliar; materials bear little relation to the texts adults need to use; disability access is absent; previous attendance brought no visible progress; or learners reasonably fear exposure, embarrassment or social sanction. A programme that counts places without examining these conditions may be available while remaining inaccessible in practice.

Research category
Quality Improvement Methods
Report archetype
Quality Improvement Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2006-10

Thematic Research Report

Adult Literacy Measurement: Comparability, Participation and the Limits of Self-Reported Data

A global comparative indicator study of concepts, survey methods, direct assessment, coverage, linguistic context and responsible interpretation

Adult literacy statistics are indispensable to education policy and unusually difficult to interpret. A national rate may be drawn from a census question answered by the individual, a statement made by another household member, an assumption based on schooling, a short reading task or a broader assessment of performance across several kinds of text. These methods do not necessarily measure the same construct, cover the same population or produce comparable values.

Research category
Data and Indicator Research
Report archetype
Comparative Indicator Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2006-09

Thematic Research Report

Improving the Reliability of School Development Plans through Baselines and Milestones

A global quality-improvement study of evidence, priorities, staged results, resources, participation and accountable review

A school development plan is reliable when it provides a credible account of the condition to be improved, the learner population affected, the result sought, the actions and resources required, the intermediate evidence expected and the decisions that will follow. It is unreliable when ambition is detached from a baseline, activities are treated as outcomes, milestones describe meetings rather than changed practice, or reported progress cannot be reproduced.

Research category
Quality Improvement Methods
Report archetype
Quality Improvement Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2006-08

Thematic Research Report

Reasonable Accommodation in Education: Standards, Documentation and Review

A global interpretive study of individual adjustment, inclusive education, evidence, proportionality and accountable decisions

Equal access to education cannot be secured only through rules written for an assumed average learner. A school, college or education authority may apply the same timetable, admission method, communication form, assessment condition or physical arrangement to everyone and still exclude a learner whose participation requires an individual change. Reasonable accommodation provides a disciplined way to examine that requirement.

Research category
Standards Interpretation
Report archetype
Standards Interpretive Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2006-07

Thematic Research Report

Public Responsibilities in the Governance of Non-Public Education Provision

A global policy study of public obligations, provider entry, minimum standards, learner protection, financing, information and accountable oversight

Non-public education is part of many national systems. It includes institutions established by communities, religious bodies, charitable organisations, families, employers and commercial enterprises; independent and publicly funded providers; and formal, non-formal, school, vocational and higher-education provision. The legal form, public purpose and degree of State support differ. A coherent governance framework must recognise this plurality without treating public responsibility as transferable.

Research category
Industry Policy and Regional Regulatory Analysis
Report archetype
Policy and Regulatory Synthesis
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2006-06

Thematic Research Report

Household Disadvantage and Participation in Education: A Disaggregation Protocol

A global methodological study of household survey populations, welfare groupings, participation measures and inequality reporting

National education averages can improve while children in particular household circumstances remain outside school, attend irregularly or leave without completing basic education. Household surveys and population censuses can reveal differences associated with resources, residence, sex, household composition, parental education, language, work and other circumstances that school returns do not observe consistently. Their capacity to disaggregate is a public asset, but it also creates risks of weak classification, unstable estimates, causal overstatement and the statistical disappearance of children outside the household sampling frame.

Research category
Data and Indicator Research
Report archetype
Comparative Indicator Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2006-05

Thematic Research Report

Completion, Repetition and Late Entry: A Cohort-Based View of Basic Education Quality

A comparative indicator study of progression, age-for-grade, completion and the interpretation of administrative and household evidence

Completion is a central test of whether a basic education system converts the right to enter school into a sustained educational opportunity. It is not, however, a single observable event with one universal measure. Administrative statistics may count new entrants to the final grade against the population of official graduation age. School records may trace the progress of a reconstructed cohort. Household surveys may establish whether children of a given age attend school or have completed a level. Each approach answers a different question and carries different error.

Research category
Data and Indicator Research
Report archetype
Comparative Indicator Study
Geographic scope
Global
ICEQC-R-2006-04

Thematic Research Report

Cross-Border Education Provision: Public Information, Learner Protection and Regulatory Cooperation

A global policy study of provider responsibility, programme status, awards, recognition, redress and cooperation across jurisdictions

Cross-border education permits learners to study with a provider, awarding institution or programme connected to another jurisdiction. It can widen access, extend specialist provision and strengthen academic cooperation. It can also divide responsibility among institutions and authorities in ways that make programme status, academic control, award rights, recognition and redress difficult for learners to establish.

Research category
Industry Policy and Regional Regulatory Analysis
Report archetype
Policy and Regulatory Synthesis
Geographic scope
Global